Review Findings for Evidence Strength

Review major report findings against their actual evidence, contrary cases and limits on inference.

What You Need
Provide the findings text, linked source tables or excerpts, methods, limitations and any relevant disaggregation rules.
Choose This Prompt When
Use this to examine whether findings are supported. Choose Review a Limitations Disclosure to review stated caveats, or Review Recommendations for Actionability to assess the proposed actions.

Review major findings against their actual evidence. Request the findings text, methods/limitations and linked tables, excerpts or records; a citation or dataset title alone does not verify its contents.

Check claim-specific source traceability for quantitative, qualitative, document and observation evidence. Assess corroboration, alternatives, source independence and shared biases for each claim, not method count; suitable single-method evidence can be valid. Look for contrary evidence and cherry-picking, distinguish descriptive/analytical/judgmental statements and flag inference beyond support. Review selective nonresponse, recall bias or weak single-source foundations without disclosed limits, plus relevant safe disaggregation without unstable small-cell conclusions.

Locate claims and distinguish evidence unavailable for verification from an observed reporting defect. State what missing quality/source detail prevents assessing, then continue supported review; invent no data, quotes, sources or completed checks.

Return overall assessment, a finding/evidence/strength/action table, must-fix/should-fix revisions and claims to downgrade or remove without stronger support. Use Strong, Moderate, Limited or Not assessable with explicit claim-specific reasons, plus justified Not applicable. Numbers require supplied anchors. Planned checks are not completed ones, and review advice does not certify evidence quality.

Loading saved answers...