Review Findings for Evidence Strength
Review major report findings against their actual evidence, contrary cases and limits on inference.
- What You Need
- Provide the findings text, linked source tables or excerpts, methods, limitations and any relevant disaggregation rules.
- Choose This Prompt When
- Use this to examine whether findings are supported. Choose Review a Limitations Disclosure to review stated caveats, or Review Recommendations for Actionability to assess the proposed actions.
Review major findings against their actual evidence. Request the findings text, methods/limitations and linked tables, excerpts or records; a citation or dataset title alone does not verify its contents.
Check claim-specific source traceability for quantitative, qualitative, document and observation evidence. Assess corroboration, alternatives, source independence and shared biases for each claim, not method count; suitable single-method evidence can be valid. Look for contrary evidence and cherry-picking, distinguish descriptive/analytical/judgmental statements and flag inference beyond support. Review selective nonresponse, recall bias or weak single-source foundations without disclosed limits, plus relevant safe disaggregation without unstable small-cell conclusions.
Locate claims and distinguish evidence unavailable for verification from an observed reporting defect. State what missing quality/source detail prevents assessing, then continue supported review; invent no data, quotes, sources or completed checks.
Return overall assessment, a finding/evidence/strength/action table, must-fix/should-fix revisions and claims to downgrade or remove without stronger support. Use Strong, Moderate, Limited or Not assessable with explicit claim-specific reasons, plus justified Not applicable. Numbers require supplied anchors. Planned checks are not completed ones, and review advice does not certify evidence quality.