ESSA Tiers of Evidence: Plain-Language Guide

Prompts for This Topic
On This Page

The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) sorts evidence for education programs into four tiers: strong, moderate, promising, and demonstrates a rationale. This guide explains each tier, which programs need which, and how to document yours.

ESSA tiers of evidence are four levels the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) uses to describe how strongly research supports an education program, practice or intervention. They come from section 8101(21)(A) of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), as amended by ESSA, which defines an evidence-based intervention as one supported by strong evidence, moderate evidence, promising evidence, or evidence that demonstrates a rationale.

This guide is for school and district staff, nonprofits that partner with schools, and anyone writing a Title I to IV application. It does not cover student testing or classroom assessment.

The Four Tiers

The table follows a state education agency's summary of the federal definitions (North Dakota Department of Public Instruction). Read the statute and the current federal guidance for the exact wording before you cite a tier in an application.

TierNameWhat supports it
1Strong evidenceOne or more well-designed and well-implemented randomized controlled experimental studies, with favorable results
2Moderate evidenceOne or more well-designed and well-implemented quasi-experimental studies, showing a statistically significant and positive effect on the outcome
3Promising evidenceOne or more well-designed and well-implemented correlational studies with statistical controls for selection bias, showing a statistically significant and positive effect on the outcome
4Demonstrates a rationaleA well-defined logic model or theory of action, supported by research, with some efforts underway by a state, district or outside research organization to determine its effectiveness

In plain words: tier 1 means a true experiment, tier 2 a study with a comparison group that was not randomly assigned, tier 3 a study of relationships that controls for who ended up in the program, and tier 4 a research-based plan that is being tested.

Which Programs Need Which Tier

According to the same state summary:

  • Interventions under Title I, Section 1003 (School Improvement) must have strong, moderate or promising evidence (tiers 1 to 3).
  • All other programs under Titles I to IV can rely on tiers 1 to 4.

Always check the notice of funding or the state application, since a state or competition can set its own requirement.

How to Find and Document Evidence

  1. Name the intervention exactly. Use its product name, grade levels and dosage. A tier belongs to a specific intervention studied with a specific population, not to a whole topic.
  2. Search for studies. The Institute of Education Sciences (IES) runs the What Works Clearinghouse, and its page on evidence-based practice links to an "ESSA Tiers of Evidence" document and a guide to using the Clearinghouse to find tiers.
  3. Check the match. Compare the study's students, setting and outcome with yours. A tier 1 study of a program in another setting does not prove it will work for your students.
  4. Record the source. Write the study, year, design, sample and result next to the tier you claim.
  5. If you have only a rationale (tier 4), build it. A tier 4 claim needs a well-defined logic model or theory of change, research that supports it, and a plan to study the results. A tier 4 claim is not enough where tiers 1 to 3 are required.

Worked example (illustrative)

The following is an illustrative scenario, not a documented case. A rural school district in the Pacific Northwest picks a reading tutoring program for grades 2 and 3 under a school improvement plan. Because section 1003 requires tiers 1 to 3, the literacy coach searches the Clearinghouse, finds two quasi-experimental studies of the program, records their design and results, and checks that the students in them are like the district's. She files the citations with the application as tier 2 evidence. The district also writes a one-page logic model and an evaluation plan so it can report its own results.

Common Mistakes

Treating a tier as a quality label for a whole program. A tier describes the evidence for an intervention in the setting where it was studied.

Citing tier 4 where tiers 1 to 3 are required. Check the program section before you choose.

Claiming a tier from a vendor's marketing. Find the study and read what it tested.

Stopping at the tier. A tier 1 intervention still needs local monitoring. Pair it with indicators and a baseline for your own students.

Sources

ESEA section 8101(21)(A), as summarized by the North Dakota Department of Public Instruction (Evidence-Based Interventions Under the ESSA) and the US Department of Education's Institute of Education Sciences. This page has not been checked line by line against the Department's 2016 non-regulatory guidance Using Evidence to Strengthen Education Investments; read it before you cite a tier. This page is not legal advice.

Did this page help?

Need help with this work?

See services