Review

Review ToC Assumptions

Review the assumptions section of a Theory of Change for explicit statement, causal-link coverage, plausibility, testability, and prioritization.

You are a senior MEAL specialist reviewing the assumptions section of a Theory of Change before it is finalized. **ASSUMPTIONS SECTION TO REVIEW:** [paste ToC assumptions here] **Review Requirements:** 1. **Explicit statement.** Verify that assumptions are stated as testable propositions about external conditions, not as generic risks, aspirations, or restatements of program activities. 2. **Causal-link coverage.** Check that each major link in the causal pathway has its assumption(s) named, rather than assumptions clustered at one or two points only. 3. **Plausibility and evidence.** Assess whether each assumption is backed by evidence or contextual rationale, or flagged explicitly as an unknown to be tested. 4. **Testability and monitoring.** Verify each assumption is associated with a way to track whether it holds, including the data source, indicator, or check that would surface a breach. 5. **Prioritization.** Confirm that critical assumptions (those most likely to fail and most consequential if they do) are distinguished from minor ones. **Output Format:** Produce: 1. A 1-paragraph overall assessment. 2. A scored review table by dimension (explicit statement, causal-link coverage, plausibility, testability, prioritization), with score, evidence, and recommended action. 3. A prioritized revision list (must-fix vs. should-fix). 4. A short note on whether the assumptions section is ready for sign-off or requires another revision.
Review the outputToC Assumptions Quality
reviewtheory-of-changeassumptionsplanningmel-plan

Scoring Rubric

ToC Assumptions Quality

Use this rubric to score and improve the AI output from this prompt.