Review Ethical Standards
Review the ethical standards in a methodology, evaluation design, or research protocol.
On this page
- What You Need
- Paste the deliverable and relevant consent, data, safeguarding, review-body and jurisdiction rules if available.
- Choose This Prompt When
- Use this for ethics across deliverable types; use ethical-compliance review for a collection plan specifically.
Review the supplied deliverable's ethical protections for its actual purpose, participant groups and stage. Request substantive text and relevant safe consent, data, risk, referral and oversight evidence; a plan or title is not implemented practice or approval.
Assess five areas:
- Applicable consent information, choice and participant-specific protections. A planning/reporting document may reference a separate approved process; unseen procedures remain unverified.
- Confidentiality and data protection: handling, de-identification, re-identification risk, retention/disposal and breach arrangements. Removing names does not guarantee anonymity.
- Do-no-harm: material risks, sensitive disclosures, cultural fit and feasible referrals.
- Positionality, participant/institutional power and conflicts of interest, including reasoned mitigation.
- Applicable oversight, accountability and actual evidence of review, without inferring legal compliance or permission to collect.
Cite safe locations and distinguish a documented omission from unavailable evidence, conflicting records or justified Not Applicable. Missing documents do not prove a safeguard failed or require repeating a procedure. Use Not Assessable for unknowns; score only under a supplied anchored rubric.
Return a bounded assessment; dimension/evidence/status/action table; must-fix/should-fix priorities with material participant risks referred to responsible authorities before affected collection; and what is ready for authorized ethics review, still unverified or in need of specialist action. No documentation score grants ethics or collection clearance.
Worked Example
Illustration only. The setting and figures are invented to show the pattern.
Scenario: An evaluation team for an adolescent health program in three districts has written its methodology section. A program lead wants the ethics content looked at before it goes to an ethics board.
What You Give the AI: The methodology text, which mentions "informed consent obtained" in one line, a paragraph on data storage, a note that interviewers are program staff, and no mention of referrals. The ethics approval letter was not supplied.
What the AI Might Return: A table by area with evidence, status and action. Consent is Not Assessable: the text points to a process but gives no wording or choice for under-18 participants. Confidentiality shows names removed from transcripts while village and age remain, flagged as a re-identification risk. Positionality is marked Needs Revision, because interviewers are program staff and the text says nothing on how that affects answers. Oversight is Not Assessable without the letter. Must-fix items include a referral route before any adolescent interviews.
When to Choose This Prompt
- You have a methodology, evaluation design or research protocol and want its ethics content examined by area.
- The document is a plan or report, so consent and data procedures may live in a separate approved text you want to see referenced.
- You want a short list of what an ethics specialist should look at before collection.
When Not to Choose It
- The thing you hold is a data collection plan and you want it checked against ethical guidelines. Review Ethical Compliance of a Data Collection Plan
- You want items in a survey or guide checked for harm one by one. Do No Harm Review of M&E Tools
- Your concern is children, survivors or other at-risk groups specifically. Review Vulnerable Population Protections
- You need a submission written for an ethics board. Create an Ethics Review / IRB Submission
Checking the Output
- Match each status against the text. Where the review says consent is covered, the passage it cites should say who gives it and what choices exist.
- A plan that refers to a separate consent process should read as unverified. Treat any verdict that it works as unearned.
- Check the confidentiality row for details that could identify someone once names are gone, such as place, role or age.
- Compare the positionality comments with who actually collects data and who commissioned the work.
- Look for the line between documented omission and unavailable evidence. The two need different follow-ups.
- Check that the closing note leaves approval and legal compliance with the people responsible for them.
Common Problems and Fixes
- The review finds safeguards missing when only a summary was pasted. Fix: Add the consent text, data protocol or referral section, or accept Not Assessable.
- It tells you to repeat consent procedures already done. Fix: List which procedures were completed, so the review covers what remains.
- Anonymity is declared because names are removed. Fix: Have it examine what else in the data could identify a person.
- Each ethical standard receives a number, yet no anchor describes what earns it. Fix: Use statuses unless you supply an anchored rubric.
Adapting It to Your Context
- Research with an ethics board: Paste the board's requirements and ask which of the five areas your text leaves unmet.
- Evaluation without a formal board: Say who does oversee ethics (a donor, an internal lead), so the oversight row can be judged against them.
- Cross-cultural settings: Add the local norms around consent and authority, and ask the review to test cultural fit.