Assess Secondary Data for a New M&E Question
Check whether an existing dataset can support a new question, with claim-specific fit, provenance, coverage and use conditions.
- What You Need
- Supply the new question/claims, original collection purpose and codebook, actual safe extract or substantive summaries, version/processing history, coverage and documented intended-use terms.
- Choose This Prompt When
- Use this when repurposing data collected for another purpose. Choose Review Indicator Sources and Methods for an indicator-source specification, Review Data Quality for quality diagnosis, or Review a Sampling Frame for selection coverage.
Assess secondary data for each actual new question/claim, separately from permission to use it. Request purpose/audience/estimand/population/unit/place/time, original collection/codebook, safe source content, versions/processing and use terms. No restricted personal records where metadata/aggregates suffice. Missing content supports a conditional plan, not findings or inferred permission.
Inventory actual extract, collection purpose/process, custodian if known, dates, coverage and provenance. Reputation, credentials, platform/dashboard label or public availability establishes neither suitability nor rights. Crosswalk each claim to real field/item, original definition/unit/coding, denominator/period/inclusion and classify direct fit, limited proxy, incompatible or unknown. Make derived formulas/assumptions explicit. Records/events/households/people are different; service users are not population prevalence.
Examine selection/reporting, duplicates/repeats, incentives, registration/access exclusions, eligibility/capture changes, missing reports and nonresponse. Match denominator unit/coverage/time and separate covered units from target. Administrative data need not be census; large need not be representative; absent records do not prove absent events. State geographic/aggregation limits on individual/subgroup claims.
Trace actual versus proposed extraction, cleaning, recoding, deduplication, linkage and aggregation with versions. Check definition/method changes before pooling/trends. Calculate only authorized supported reproducible quantities; no invented history, matches or weights. QA alone proves neither construct validity nor causal identification; this assessment authorizes no linkage/recovery.
In a separate permitted-use column cite supplied consent/purpose, agreement/license, custodian and institutional terms for this specific purpose/environment/linkage/retention/disclosure. Mark evidenced/conflicting/unknown; seek actual owner clarification. Access, pseudonymization or analytic fitness is not permission, anonymity or compliance. Unclear sensitive use stays pending while safe metadata review continues.
Return claim-specific suitability/coverage/comparability/use-status/transformation/checks/unknowns matrix and conditional narrower-use, pending, incompatible or not-assessable recommendation. Analytic suitability does not override unresolved permission or use restrictions. Provide verification priorities and provenance/reporting limits, including alternative question/source/prospective evidence needs. No association-to-impact or reuse/publication approval claim.